Javascript Redirect

Friday, March 9, 2012

"It’s been an interesting journey"

My good friend and colleague Chuck Conway is retiring from his second career in water pollution control – and what careers he's had. He shared reflections of his (rather colorful) life in the worlds of government and training and Vietnam. And he granted me permission to share them with you. 


It's a good read for anyone interested in the early days of water pollution control, in how government often works, and the ups and downs that got us where we are today. 


And it reminds us that the people behind the scenes are human beings made in the image and likeness of God – people who have moms, make sacrifices, are never perfect, and seek to do good. So sit back, relax, and enjoy this quite interesting journey  . . .



Monday, February 27, 2012

"The covenant between me and you and every living creature"

In the first reading at Mass yesterday – the first Sunday of Lent – Catholics were reminded of Noah. This was followed by St. Peter’s epistle, which expanded the flood imagery with the promises of baptism. Both readings then contrasted wonderfully with the Gospel’s scene in the desert. As I was listening to these texts, each echoed a subject that of late has been the focus of much discussion: the place of man within creation.
God said to Noah and to his sons with him:
"See, I am now establishing my covenant with you
and your descendants after you
and with every living creature that was with you:
all the birds, and the various tame and wild animals
that were with you and came out of the ark.
I will establish my covenant with you,
that never again shall all bodily creatures be destroyed
by the waters of a flood;
there shall not be another flood to devastate the earth."
God added: "This is the sign that I am giving for all ages to come, of the covenant between me and you
and every living creature with you:
I set my bow in the clouds to serve as a sign
of the covenant between me and the earth.
When I bring clouds over the earth,
and the bow appears in the clouds,
I will recall the covenant I have made
between me and you and all living beings,
so that the waters shall never again become a flood
to destroy all mortal beings." (Gen. 9:8-15)
There’s a lot going on here, but the common theme in God’s promise to Noah is that He will forevermore safeguard earth and all living beings from His just judgment. Indeed, Genesis doesn't limit God’s promise exclusively to the human race, but “to every living creature.” This makes sense since, in the beginning, God found all that He had made to be “very good.” (Of course, we’ll see echoes of all this in the psalms of creation and, ultimately, in the promise of a new Heaven and a new Earth in John’s Apocalypse.)

What have been revealed to us in Scripture, then, are balancing forces that teach us what God is up to by granting us “dominion” over creation (Gen. 1:28-29). This is helpful. Exactly what man’s dominant place is within the scheme of earthly resources (living or otherwise) has been debated for some time, especially since the coming of the Age of Industry. Of late, it’s been highlighted in the presidential races here in America.

One comment reported recently by former Senator Rick Santorum especially caught my attention: “Unlike the earth, we're intelligent and we can actually manage things."

I think I know what he means by this, but the theologian and environmental regulator in me have something to add.

Ages ago, I had it explained to me (and I do forget who said this, for which I apologize) that the theology and anthropology of the meaning of dominion in Genesis is more akin to a parent-child relationship than it is to a master-slave relationship. Following the metaphor, we humans are to be wise and care for creation, but we are not beholden to it. We are to put it to use for the good of the human family, but not assault it for our whims and pleasure.

Better yet, in the language of love, we are to embrace it and allow it to seek our good, as we seek its good. This may seem to be odd language when speaking of man’s relation with the rest of creation. But it sounds consistent with what has been revealed to us about God:
"See, I am now establishing my covenant with you
and your descendants after you
and with every living creature that was with you:
all the birds, and the various tame and wild animals
that were with you and came out of the ark.
I will establish my covenant with you,
that never again shall all bodily creatures be destroyed
by the waters of a flood;
there shall not be another flood to devastate the earth."
Simply put, if God holds a covenant with all living creatures, and we are made in His image, shouldn't we also seek a covenant with earth’s ecological bounty? And if so, how far do our responsibilities go to protect it?

Here we come to another point: Just because God will not devastate the earth does not imply that He would not allow us to do so. Thanks to our free will, we may take too much and pollute too much and waste too much and, thus, destroy a great many bodily creatures – plant, animal, and human. Sure, we probably will not obliterate all life on earth, but we certainly may leave our mark. We are, after all, sinners.

And here we come back to Senator Santorum’s statement that “we're intelligent and we can actually manage things.”

Yes, we can manage things, but we can also be very poor at it, which is why I have a job. Yes, many of us do care about conserving the goods of nature, but then there are others that don’t, no matter what their intelligence. Which is why I have a job. Greed, after all, is sometimes a stronger force than our wits.

Thus, we do well to remember that it is not our intelligence that makes us good stewards, but our intellect elevated and emboldened by the grace of God. It is not our minds that foster good decision making, but our redeemed hearts. It is God, not us, that alone can claim a perfect covenant with the great good of the natural order. We consumers, regulators, scientists, politicians, and chief executive officers need to work very hard at managing things at all – sinners that we are.

Wednesday, February 22, 2012

Lent 2012: Life, brotherhood, and communion

The good is whatever gives, protects and promotes life, brotherhood and communion.  Pope Benedict XVI. 2012 Lenten Message.

The Holy Father's Lenten Message for 2012 is a must read, and I pray that many of the faithful will hear some of it from the pulpit or read it in their parish bulletins or web sites. As usual, his words astound. I encourage you to read the message in its entirety.

I was particularly struck with the urgency with which he connected caring for our neighbor with two related issues that are dear to him – unity and love. Moreover, it is telling how his words speak so deeply to events here at home in America and within the pro-life world.

As I’ve been posting about recently, we’ve seen schism between those who see life issues as only abortion, euthanasia, and embryonic stem-cell research and others, like the Holy Father, who dare to expand the matter of life to the ecological systems that keep humanity breathing, fed, and happily hydrated. While I understand why my brothers and sisters devoted to ending abortion, etc., wish to keep the wagons circled tightly around a few specific and wantonly deadly issues, I shudder at the lack of loving dialogue that one often finds in needless debates about what is and what is not a pro-life issue.

We also hear voices – most often in the political world – that criticize the science of climate change, and this also brings bickering rather than dialogue.

Enter the Holy Father, who reminds us that there is a Christian way to disagree, and it is rooted in love and a dedication to the truth. 
Scripture tells us that even “the upright falls seven times” (Prov 24:16); all of us are weak and imperfect (cf. 1 Jn 1:8). It is a great service, then, to help others and allow them to help us, so that we can be open to the whole truth about ourselves, improve our lives and walk more uprightly in the Lord’s ways. There will always be a need for a gaze which loves and admonishes, which knows and understands, which discerns and forgives (cf. Lk 22:61), as God has done and continues to do with each of us. 
In other words, since none of us are perfect, each of us needs each other.

Let this Lent, then, be a time of love and dialogue between those who seek Christ’s truths, a search that is related in many ways to understanding how our sinful natures and overconsumption is damaging the goodness and unity of God’s creation. 

As the Holy Father teaches:
 The Lord’s disciples, united with him through the Eucharist, live in a fellowship that binds them one to another as members of a single body. This means that the other is part of me, and that his or her life, his or her salvation, concern my own life and salvation. Here we touch upon a profound aspect of communion: our existence is related to that of others, for better or for worse. Both our sins and our acts of love have a social dimension. This reciprocity is seen in the Church, the mystical body of Christ: the community constantly does penance and asks for the forgiveness of the sins of its members, but also unfailingly rejoices in the examples of virtue and charity present in her midst. As Saint Paul says: “Each part should be equally concerned for all the others” (1 Cor 12:25), for we all form one body. Acts of charity towards our brothers and sisters – as expressed by almsgiving, a practice which, together with prayer and fasting, is typical of Lent – is rooted in this common belonging. Christians can also express their membership in the one body which is the Church through concrete concern for the poorest of the poor. Concern for one another likewise means acknowledging the good that the Lord is doing in others and giving thanks for the wonders of grace that Almighty God in his goodness continuously accomplishes in his children. When Christians perceive the Holy Spirit at work in others, they cannot but rejoice and give glory to the heavenly Father (cf. Mt 5:16).

Thursday, February 16, 2012

The ecology of contact

Recent gospel readings remind us of a peculiar trait in Christ’s ministry to the sick: When healing them, he touched them.

Of course, such touching of the sick would have been unheard of among the Jews of Jesus’ day. It was a violation of the Law of Moses. It was a radical departure from what the Nation of Israel knew of love of neighbor. It was, therefore, subversive and dangerous.

Yet it was, and is, the way of Christ.

The Holy Father calls this to mind beautifully in his February 12th Angelus, to people standing in the chilly Roman air of St. Peter’s Square:
While Jesus was going about the villages of Galilee preaching, a leper came up and besought him: “If you will, you can make me clean”. Jesus did not shun contact with that man; on the contrary, impelled by deep participation in his condition, he stretched out his hand and touched the man — overcoming the legal prohibition — and said to him: “I will; be clean.” 
That gesture and those words of Christ contain the whole history of salvation, they embody God’s will to heal us, to purify us from the illness that disfigures us and ruins our relationships. In that contact between Jesus’ hand and the leper, every barrier between God and human impurity, between the Sacred and its opposite, was pulled down. This was not of course in order to deny evil and its negative power, but to demonstrate that God’s love is stronger than all illness, even in its most contagious and horrible form. Jesus took upon himself our infirmities, he made himself “a leper” so that we might be cleansed. 
A splendid existential comment on this Gospel is the well known experience of St Francis of Assisi, which he sums up at the beginning of his Testament: “This is how the Lord gave me, Brother Francis, the power to do penance. When I was in sin the sight of lepers was too bitter for me. And the Lord himself led me among them, and I pitied and helped them. And when I left them I discovered that what had seemed bitter to me was changed into sweetness in my soul and body. And shortly afterward I rose and left the world.” 
In those lepers whom Francis met when he was still “in sin” — as he says — Jesus was present; and when Francis approached one of them, overcoming his own disgust, he embraced him, Jesus healed him from his “leprosy”, namely, from his pride, and converted him to love of God. This is Christ’s victory which is our profound healing and our resurrection to new life! 
Dear friends, let us turn in prayer to the Virgin Mary, whom we celebrated yesterday commemorating her Apparitions in Lourdes. Our Lady gave St. Bernadette an ever timely message: the invitation to prayer and penance. Through his Mother it is always Jesus who comes to meet us to set us free from every sickness of body and of soul. Let us allow ourselves to be touched and cleansed by him and to treat our brethren with compassion!
For Catholic ecologists, the presence of St. Francis in the Holy Father’s words are especially meaningful. Here we remember that the patron of the environment was a lover of people – especially the poor and sick. Indeed, St. Francis lived the Gospel by remembering that human contact has a purpose beyond the superficial pleasures that the world so often celebrates. For disciples of Christ, and all those of good will that seek the eternal truth, human contact is a physical acknowledgement and foretaste of the promised communion of Heaven.

This is why we see contact among the living and the dead throughout the natural order. From biological reproduction to affectionate hugs to the consoling holding of hands, the human person mirrors the greater ecological world, which thrives by bringing the bounty of biota in contact with itself, with the elements of water and air, with fertile soils and even the arid sands of deserts.

At its core, ecology is the sum of all contact. It is a sacramental sign of what it means to be together in communion with, and made in the image and likeness of, the Triune God.

Wednesday, February 15, 2012

Church and state: life and the physics of the Gospel

What should the state do when an archbishop complains about government policies?

According to many in America today, the Church should be silent. This is the refrain we hear over and again when discussing federally mandated insurance for artificial contraception and abortifacients.

But one wonders if this refrain is being sung – and if so, by whom – about an archbishop in the Philippines who has been a harsh critic of his government's environmental practices, especially related to mining.

Here’s some of a report from BusinessMirror.com, a Philippine publication: 
CAGAYAN DE ORO CITY—The highest official of the Roman Catholic Church here has reiterated his call early Monday night for a moratorium on mining activities even as he hit claims that mining has not contributed to the devastation wrought by Typhoon Sendong last December.
Mayor Vicente Emano said that he had issued “special permits” to mine several hectares in the city’s hinterlands and had not suspended these operations despite snowballing calls for him to halt theses operations. Most members of the City Council here have supported the mayor’s stance.
“I admit I have granted special permits; the law allows me to do that. But [the mining operations] must not destroy the ecology,” Emano said, adding that he will only order the stop of all mining operations in the city if a study conducted immediately “shows that mining operations have destroyed the environment.”
“Only then will we immediately order the cancellation of the permits,” he said.
Archbishop Antonio J. Ledesma, SJ, DD, a long and staunch defender of the environment, has repeatedly called for a stop to all mining operations in the city and in the country and has scored the seeming “business as usual” stance of city government officials following the devastation caused by Sendong.
“It is unconscionable for city officials to adopt a ‘business as usual’ attitude for mining permits to continue,” Ledesma said in his homily during the early Monday night Eucharistic celebration at the St. Augustine Metropolitan Cathedral marking the opening of the “DCM and Bishops’ Forum on Typhoon Sendong and its challenges for Mindanao” as well as a thanksgiving celebration for the 60th anniversary of the archdiocese. 
I would imagine that many on the eco-left would praise the archbishop for his moxie. But here in America, many on the left are excoriating the Church for its fight against artificial birth control mandates and other “progressive” government activities.

Some would rightfully say that the issues of mining and contraceptive coverage are wildly different. But they also have much in common. Both have adherents that speak of freedom and the livelihoods of those who have little. Both have detractors who claim that no good can justify an evil. To this, the adherents of both issues tell us that there really are no evils, and that in such matter detractors like the Church should mind their manners and say nothing.

I do not wish to oversimplify complex matters. Chemically induced abortions and contraception are deeply pastoral matters that affect people in drastic, intricate, and permanent ways. Much can be said of the balance between jobs, the public well-being, and the protection of the natural world.

But there is this simple point: Those who disagree with the Church on a particular matter would rather she be silent and not speak against dearly held views, whereas those who agree with the Church delight when she finds her voice.

Here, we should call to mind an issue we can all agree on: the desegregation of schools. In the 1950s and early 1960s, Archbishop Rummel of New Orleans was ahead of the national curve as he fought to desegregate Catholic schools – that is, as he sought to realign the cultural views of his flock with the Gospel of Jesus Christ. This fight escalated until he had no choice but to declare as excommunicate a number of local officials for their resistance to Church teachings. Was that a wanton entrance into secular affairs by the Church, or was it just the right thing to do?

No one should underestimate the Gospel’s power to inconvenience, and to do so in differing ways. Indeed, the truths of the Gospel are like the physical laws that saturate the cosmos. They do not appear only when called. They simply exist, and we must adapt to them.

And so, just as no one should debate a physicist about the laws of gravity when one’s mishandled tea cup shatters on the floor – or debate an ecologist when toxins poison your liver or the countryside yonder – so it is unhelpful to debate a bishop when he simply states that the laws of the human cosmos cannot be violated without causing harm, and that it is wrong to force people to bring about the damage.

Wednesday, February 8, 2012

"That they may be brought to perfection as one"

It’s always depressing to watch Christians fight – especially those so dedicated to the Gospel of Life. But today was a day when the forces of division won small battles in the war for love, unity, and life.

As reported in the Evangelical Environmental Network (EEN),
Today during an Energy & Commerce hearing that covered the health impacts of mercury on the unborn Rep. John Shimkus (R-Ill) challenged Rev. Mitch Hescox, President & CEO, of the Evangelical Environmental Network (EEN) on his pro-life views.
"The life in pro-life denotes not quality of life but life itself," said Rep. Shimkus.
EEN’s blog also refers to a statement of the Cornwall Alliance, which made a staunch defense of maintaining the purity of what it means to be pro-life. The Alliance is not pleased about any association of mercury poisoning with issues such as abortion, euthanasia, and embryonic stem-cell research. Here’s some of their statement:
Consequently, calling mercury pollution and similar environmental causes pro-life obscures the meaning of pro-life. And thanking politicians with 100% pro-abortion voting records (even some who support partial-birth abortion) for their “pro-life” position because they supported restrictions on mercury emissions, while rebuking some with 100% pro-life voting records because they opposed or didn’t support the new restrictions, as EEN’s campaign did, will confuse voters, divide the pro-life vote, and postpone the end of abortion on demand in America.
This doesn’t mean we should ignore environmental risks. It does mean they should not be portrayed as pro-life. Genuinely pro-life people will usually desire to reduce other risks as well—guided by cost/benefit analysis. But to call those issues “pro-life” is to obscure the meaning of the term. 
Two fundamental principles distinguish truly pro-life issues (like abortion, euthanasia, and embryonic stem cell research) from environmental issues. First and foremost, truly pro-life issues are issues of actual life and death, while environmental issues tend to be matters of health. Second, truly pro-life issues address actual intent to kill innocent people, whether the unborn, the gravely ill, or the aged, while environmental issues do not. [Emphasis original]
If environmental advocates still want to support mercury-emission reductions or other environmental causes, let them do so honestly and above board. But they should not promote those causes under the pro-life banner. That is at best badly misinformed, at worst dishonest.
We call on environmentalists to cease portraying such causes as pro-life and join us in working diligently to reduce and end abortion on demand in the United States, which every year kills about 1.2 million babies, amounting to over 54 million in the 39 years since the Supreme Court’s Roe v. Wade decision.
News of this statement was picked up by The Hill, and the reader commentary below the story shows just how damaging all this is to the credibility of those who defend human life.

As I’ve stated often in this blog and in my columns – and as Pope Benedict XVI states in Caritas in Veritate, words which hover at the top of this blog – there is a link between human life and the environment. To be clear: a link is not an equivalency, but it is a relationship – and relationships are the infrastructure of what it means to be Christian.

Let this point also be clear: The slaughter of the unborn, which we euphemistically call abortion, is a symptom and an effect of our cultural cooperation with evil. Our shared goal, then, is to change the cultural acceptance of this cooperation. And so, if it takes a certain rational approach to change the hearts of some, and another rational approach to change the hearts of others, and a third, fourth, and fifth rational approach to change the hearts of many others, who would be against this? Is there but one way to preach the Gospel? Does not St. Paul remind us that there are many parts to the body, all with their own God-given gifts?
Therefore, I tell you that nobody speaking by the spirit of God says, “Jesus be accursed.” And no one can say, “Jesus is Lord,” except by the holy Spirit. There are different kinds of spiritual gifts but the same Spirit; there are different forms of service but the same Lord; there are different workings but the same God who produces all of them in everyone. To each individual the manifestation of the Spirit is given for some benefit. To one is given through the Spirit the expression of wisdom; to another the expression of knowledge according to the same Spirit; to another faith by the same Spirit; to another gifts of healing by the one Spirit; to another mighty deeds; to another prophecy; to another discernment of spirits; to another varieties of tongues; to another interpretation of tongues. But one and the same Spirit produces all of these, distributing them individually to each person as he wishes. (1 Corinthians 12:3-11)
Anti-abortion advocates can help their cause by allowing others, if this is their calling, to work for both human life and ecological ends, and to do so under the same titular umbrella. Indeed, there are many goods that can come from the dialogue between issues such as abortion and the public health implications of ecology. Here's one: When a person includes particular ecological issues in their definition of pro-life advocacy, they incarnationally mix among those whose more narrow ecological concerns can then become a path to conversion – to an adoption of the Gospel of Life and, thus, to become as convinced as anyone of the evil of murdering unborn children. Ecology, then, is not an enemy in the war against abortion. It is a weapon and a tool, one which we cast aside at our peril, and the peril of many, many unborn souls.

And so, shall we scatter, each in our own tribe, to the delight of our enemy? Or shall we come together and support the unique good works of each other?

In the hopes of the latter, I contacted the Cornwall Alliance this evening and thanked them for the good work that they do, without mentioning our differences, and offered my help as applicable. I here do the same for the folks at EEN. I make such offers in hope that in Christian fellowship, we can all do our share in defeating the forces of darkness and division with the words of Christ:
I pray not only for them, but also for those who will believe in me through their word, so that they may all be one, as you, Father, are in me and I in you, that they also may be in us, that the world may believe that you sent me. (John 17:20-21).

Monday, January 30, 2012

The right and wrong of the Right (and Left)

A recent commentary by Steven Cohen, writing for the Huffington Post, explores the failures of many Republicans to champion the natural environment. This follows a similar piece a few weeks back by Rick Ungar, writing in Forbes, which largely takes Rick Santorum to task.

These writers, and so many others, make a good point. In catering to the far-right elements of their base, current Republican presidential hopefuls often espouse sloppy science and are irritating many in the pro-life camp.

In part, Cohen puts it this way:
The attack on climate science and regulation seems to be red meat for the Republican primary voters this winter, but that is a pretty soft target for attack. The political problem with climate change is that its cause cannot always be seen or smelled, and its impact is largely in the future. Attacking regulation is also easy, since rules may be respected and even understood, but they are rarely loved. Still, Newt and Mitt may be forgetting something pretty fundamental: people like to breathe. A Harris poll this fall reported that 75% of Americans support stricter environmental protection. While this broke down as 90% of all Democrats and 54% of all Republicans, even those opposing most government regulation understand the need for effective policing of environmental pollution.
Part of the problem, however, is that some on the right are not all wrong when it comes to big government. And remember, I write as a government regulator as well as a Catholic ecologist. Clearly, I see the value of government watchdogs that protect the public from businesses, individuals, and even other government agencies that put profit or expediency before public health or the ecological common good.

But I also cringe when people propose that a clean world will certainly come from some new legislation and more funding of regulators like me. As the saying goes, you can’t legislate good behavior.

Few put it better than Pope Benedict XVI in his 2005 encyclical Deus Caritas Est. Embedded in this beautiful bombshell of a papal encyclical are these words about how Church and State should relate:
The Church cannot and must not take upon herself the political battle to bring about the most just society possible. She cannot and must not replace the State. Yet at the same time she cannot and must not remain on the sidelines in the fight for justice. She has to play her part through rational argument and she has to reawaken the spiritual energy without which justice, which always demands sacrifice, cannot prevail and prosper. A just society must be the achievement of politics, not of the Church. Yet the promotion of justice through efforts to bring about openness of mind and will to the demands of the common good is something which concerns the Church deeply.
Love—caritas—will always prove necessary, even in the most just society. There is no ordering of the State so just that it can eliminate the need for a service of love. Whoever wants to eliminate love is preparing to eliminate man as such. There will always be suffering which cries out for consolation and help. There will always be loneliness. There will always be situations of material need where help in the form of concrete love of neighbor is indispensable. The State which would provide everything, absorbing everything into itself, would ultimately become a mere bureaucracy incapable of guaranteeing the very thing which the suffering person—every person—needs: namely, loving personal concern.
It’s hard to keep typing after that. What can I add?

Well, maybe this: As a government regulator, ecologist, and a Catholic, I implore politicians and pundits of all ideologies to remember that the addition or rejection of human statutes and regulations mean nothing if humans can’t first embrace the eternal truths revealed to us by the God who is love.

As our Lord teaches us – Democrats, Republicans, Liberals, Conservatives, Occupiers and Tea Partiers alike – "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you (Matthew 7:12)."

Sunday, January 22, 2012

Roe vs. Wade vs. reason: Part 2

There’s been a backlash recently when ecology is catergorized as a life issue. This needs addressing.

Last year on the anniversary of Roe vs. Wade, I wrote of the hypocrisy exhibited by some who seek to save seals and rain forests but not unborn people. “For Catholic Ecologists, the link between ecological advocacy and abortion is obvious,” I wrote. “And denying this link results in angst for many so-called ‘pro-choice’ environmentalists.”

It is reasonable to claim that this works in reverse, too. Those of us who seek an end to the cultural acceptance of abortion are also called to protect earth’s ecology. As noted in this blog’s masthead quote by the Holy Father, there is a link between “our duties towards the environment” and “our duties towards the human person.”

Certainly, this link is not an equivalency. Pope Benedict is teaching us that the mystery of life – of organic, living, interconnected, reproducing entities that came into existence following natural laws that were embedded in the cosmos by God at the moment of creation – is diverse and, at the same time, unified.

Put another way, all life must be in relation if it really is life. Relation is the very being of the Triune God – the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Moreover, we are made in the image of God and, as the Book of Genesis reveals to us, human life is the pinnacle and steward of all creation. To better explore what this all means, we ponder the words of the Holy Father:
The Church has a responsibility towards creation and she must assert this responsibility in the public sphere. In so doing, she must defend not only earth, water and air as gifts of creation that belong to everyone. She must above all protect mankind from self-destruction. There is need for what might be called a human ecology, correctly understood. The deterioration of nature is in fact closely connected to the culture that shapes human coexistence: when “human ecology” is respected within society, environmental ecology also benefits. Just as human virtues are interrelated, such that the weakening of one places others at risk, so the ecological system is based on respect for a plan that affects both the health of society and its good relationship with nature.
As millions gather in Washington D.C. on this anniversary of Roe vs. Wade – an annual act of love for life that goes largely unreported by the mainstream media – we must also pause to remember the millions of children, born and unborn, and adults, that have been damaged or killed by poisons in our water, air, and food. Such causes of death are linked to – but, again, not the same type of evil as – the killing of babies in a mother’s womb.

And so we as a people of life must also familiarize ourselves with and work to end the effects of environmental poisons such as pesticides, PCBs, formaldehyde, asbestos, lead, aldrin/dieldrin, mercury, benzo(a)pyrene, mirex, chlordane, octachlorostyrene, DDT, hexachlorobenzene, dioxins and furans, and toxaphene. To name a few.

Indeed, in working with those in the ecological advocacy world who fight to protect humanity from such poisons, we can bring the Gospel of Life and expand their understanding of what it means to be an environmentalist. We must teach that to be green means to work to save the lives of the unborn.

Last point: Our ancient enemy delights in our internal squabbling. Satan wins when we isolate ourselves into subject-specific cliques that, while we are perhaps well-meaning, are not open to dialogue with those who fight other, similar battles. I saw a small defeat of such isolation on Saturday, as I joined a large gathering of Catholics that prayed the Rosary in front of an abortion mill in Cranston, Rhode Island during the early hours of a snowy day. For purposes of plowing, parking was restricted on the main streets. As I walked along unshoveled sidewalks towards the line of people praying the Rosary, I had to pass two pro-choice protestors. They didn’t know where I stood in the fight as I had just arrived and my rosary was in my pocket. We chatted about the snow and the parking ban. We joked about the city’s inability to plow the side streets, making those the safer choice for our cars. We laughed. Then I took out my rosary and proceeded to join my brothers and sisters seeking to save lives. The pro-abortion woman that I had been pleasantly chatting with gave a surprised look. Maybe she realized that she had something in common with one of the pro-life protesters. Either way, Satan must not have been happy, because for a moment, two people on opposite sides of the issue had been friendly. Our common experiences had brought us together. A road to dialogue and love was plowed clean and made passable, if only briefly.

If the war for life is to be won and won soon, we must sneak past the defenses of those who need a change of heart. We must be open to dialogue in whatever form it comes.

Thus, the point: If pro-life advocates cannot first dialogue with each other – with those who do and do not seek to connect ecology with all life issues – then how are we ever going to love, communicate with, and change the hearts of those many others who have fallen so deeply into the shadow of the culture of death?


Saturday, January 21, 2012

The Key to Keystone

President Obama’s decision this week to halt the controversial Keystone pipeline – a hyper-conduit for oil from Canada to the Gulf Coast – sparked predictable commentary from our friends on each end of the political spectrum.

Thomas Pyle, writing in FoxNews.com, summed up much of the criticism against the president’s decision. Michael Brune, Sierra Club’s executive director, wrote in the San Francisco Chronicle that we must not only thank the president, we must also rethink how to feed our insatiable hunger for energy. For a balanced look at the decision, we find this in the Washington Post.

Such balance is important. In much of the coverage of the (temporary, politically motivated?) defeat of the Keystone project, the notion that our economy and our ecology need not be at odds seems to have gotten lost. We must reclaim and proclaim this ecology-economy link.

Indeed, the interrelation inherent within both – the fact that economies and ecologies are, in their own ways, living exchanges of resources – speaks to a similarity between them. There is a dialogue between how man uses resources and how people benefit (or are harmed) because of human choices.

This calls to mind the Catholic relational worldview. Just as God’s grace and human nature, church and state, male and female, and so much more, are meant to be in relation, ecologies and economies must speak to each other. A pristine, untouched planet is not quite in humanity’s best interest, nor is one scorched and gouged for our gluttony.

As for Keystone, the project would help resuscitate our economy. But extracting and piping oil by the millions of gallons across the nation’s heartland – and its breadbasket – would certainly be an undertaking. It would come with risks: Think offshore drilling and the BP Gulf oil spill. Still, we humans have built and managed engineering marvels before. Maintaining them becomes the question, which raises the issue of dedicated humans doing their jobs, which raises the problem of Original Sin and human greed and laziness, but that’s for another column.

For now, we should note that within hours of the president’s decisions, there is talk of alternatives. Not just sustainable alternatives like wind power and solar, but a different way of working with our Canadian cousins to safely tap their energy reserves.

Environmentalists say that this is not possible – that the wicked witch is dead and must stay so. I wonder. Because the engineer in me – and my Catholic ecological sensibilities – has me wondering if we might want to discuss this a little more, if our once great ingenuity can find a way to make this work, even if temporarily. Dialogue and reason are, after all, tools we should not so easily dismiss.

I would encourage this conversation. Because without Keystone, Canada will look for other markets and they have said something about Asia. That is uncomfortable news for two reasons: If Asia gets this fuel, the planet will still be exposed to its climate-altering byproducts – perhaps even more so – and our competitors will be promised a plentiful source of easy-to-use fuel to feed their own economies and not ours.

So before we break out the champagne, let us remember that in the real world, not everyone plays by the same rules. And so, might not it be in our best interest – and the planet’s – to commit to work with Canada to develop new ways of extracting, transporting, and using this fuel source, and to do so in clean, manageable ways?

The key to Keystone, then, seems to be our American ingenuity, one that can fuel American jobs today as it helps us transition to a clean, prosperous future for Americans not yet born.

Wednesday, January 11, 2012

Communion

Today at work, my state agency opened its doors to local environmental groups, researchers, and others whose mission is ecological protection. Also attending was the Gospel, although it may have been easy to miss if you weren't paying attention.

The event's purpose was to encourage partnerships between the government and the advocates that want to help. In these days of reduced government budgets, the need to partner with others is necessary, even if it is something we should have been doing all along.

As a person of faith – which I shared in the introductions, that I was not just an engineer with my agency, but that I also worked with “faith-based groups” in the area of ecology – I listened intently as everyone shared in the conversation.

There was the schooled eco-advocate and nurse – a delightful, dignified, smiling woman who labors to build a healthy world, and so reduce the suffering she sees all too often at her job. There was the eco-lobbyist who asked for my card because she wanted to work with people of faith. There was a young man dedicated to issues of environmental justice who offered to help with an upcoming talk on the ethics of climate change.

And there was the Gospel of life, present in a small but real ways among people fighting specific battles in the greater war for life. Sure, we may not all be in agreement on every issue that I as a Catholic profess, teach, and defend. But that’s the point. We’re nonetheless building alliances and friendships and, in doing so, living in the same community, making eye contact, and shaking hands. 

Such interaction is the stuff of being Catholic because it invites strangers into friendships that encourage a greater communion.

One last observation: I was struck with what one local ecological veteran shared as he spoke about many relevant and weighty issues. He noted that for a “green economy” to be fostered there is need for a “civil renewal.” This thread of conversation didn’t receive the attention it deserved – the time was meant to begin, not complete, conversations. And anyway, I don’t think many knew what he meant by the term, nor do I for sure. But “civil renewal” did sound something like what the Holy Father has been speaking of in the use of the term “inner attitudes,” and how we must change ours if we are to confront the starvation that is killing millions.

I am always sad when Catholics or those of other faiths criticize ecology. As today’s gathering has shown me once again, ecology is a graced way of blending science, faith, and life – and in so doing, helping to bring about an authentic “civil renewal” needed for the good of all mankind.

May Saint Francis and Blessed Kateri Tekakwitha pray for all ecologists, and may we all work to offer a clean, healthy, and sustainable global community for many, many generations not yet born.